Skip to content

Science & research

Autism and parenting: why parenting mistakes are not a cause

Who is it for? For parents and relatives who blame themselves, and for professionals and interested people who want to put myths about autism and parenting into context.

Colourful wooden coloured pencils on a light background
Photo: Foto Garage AG (CC0, Wikimedia Commons)

In brief

Autism does not arise from parenting mistakes. Studies of twins and families show a strong genetic influence; the shared family environment contributes hardly anything. The assumption that mothers cause autism through coldness was refuted long ago. Parenting can make everyday life with autism easier or harder, but it is not the cause. Parents therefore deserve support instead of blame.

State of the sources. This article is based on a meta-analysis of twin studies, a Swedish register study and a review on the genetics of autism. It does not replace medical or psychotherapeutic advice.

Some parents hear that their child behaves this way because they bring them up wrongly. Such sentences often come from relatives, from the neighbourhood or even from the school environment. Especially with children who speak well and stand out little, autism is easily mistaken for parenting problems. This article explains what research says on the question whether autism or what was formerly called Asperger syndrome arises from parenting mistakes.

Research’s clear answer

No, parenting does not cause autism. There is no scientific basis for this assumption. Studies of twins and families find a negligible influence of the shared family environment. In a Swedish register study with data from millions of siblings and twins it contributed only minimally, while heritability was estimated at 83 per cent. [1]

A further study with data from five countries arrived at a median heritability of about 81 per cent; the share of shared environmental influences was negligible. [2] More on these figures is in the article Is autism hereditary?.

Where the assumption comes from

In the mid-20th century the notion spread that “cold” mothers, later called “refrigerator mothers”, caused autism in their children. The first twin study of 1977, by contrast, already showed a predominantly genetic contribution. [2] The notion burdened parents for decades and persists in some minds to this day.

Why autism is nevertheless mistaken for parenting

Autism is not visible from outside. A child who breaks down at home after a school day may seem spoilt or undisciplined to outsiders. In reality they held themselves together all day. The 2016 S3 guideline stated that behavioural problems in autism are not infrequently first interpreted differently, for example as defiance. [3] This is one reason why diagnoses sometimes come late and parents have to listen to reproaches in the meantime.

What parenting can and cannot do

Parenting does not cause autism, but it can influence how well everyday life works. Clear routines, predictable rules, places to withdraw and an understanding approach can reduce strain. These are assessments by the editorial team. How parents can act in difficult situations at home is described in the article Challenging situations at home. Programmes for parent-child interaction are presented in the article Parent-child interaction: what programmes showed.

What matters is the difference between cause and support. When parents seek help or try out methods, this is not an admission of a mistake. It is an attempt to accompany their child well. Burdened parents can get relief for themselves; more in the article Self-care for parents and relatives.

How you can deal with reproaches

Sometimes it helps to explain matter-of-factly that autism is a developmental particularity that has predominantly genetic causes and does not arise from parenting. You do not have to justify yourself. Short texts that you pass on can also help. More suggestions for conversations with grandparents, friends and your surroundings are offered by the article Informing grandparents, friends and your surroundings. The article Myths and facts about autism puts further common misconceptions into context.

You might also be interested in

Sources and literature

  1. Sandin S, Lichtenstein P, Kuja-Halkola R, et al. The heritability of autism spectrum disorder. JAMA 2017;318(12):1182–1184. doi.org/10.1001/jama.2017.12141 – Register study
  2. Thapar A, Rutter M. Genetic advances in autism. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders 2021;51(12):4321–4332. doi.org/10.1007/s10803-020-04685-z – Review article
  3. DGKJP, DGPPN et al. Autismus-Spektrum-Störungen im Kindes-, Jugend- und Erwachsenenalter. Teil 1: Diagnostik. S3-Leitlinie, AWMF-Reg.-Nr. 028-018, Textstand 23.02.2016 (Kap. B.2.6.1). – Leitlinie (abgelaufen, laut DGKJP bis 04.04.2021 gültig, dgkjp.de)

You might also be interested in

Found a mistake?

If something is factually wrong, out of date or unclear, let us know. You do not have to give any personal details.

Write a noteClose note

What is wrong? A source helps us check it. At least 10 characters.

Only for follow-up questions about this note. Deleted as soon as it has been dealt with. More in the privacy policy.

Support Autismus WissenBooks & further reading