Skip to content

Assessment & diagnosis

How stable is an early autism diagnosis?

Who is it for? For parents and professionals who want to know how reliable an autism diagnosis is in toddlerhood and what it means when professionals first wait and see.

Close-up of the growth rings of a tree stump
Photo: Gabriel Jimenez gabrielj_photography (CC0 1.0 Universal)

In brief

If autism is established in the second year of life, the diagnosis is usually confirmed later, as shown by a study of younger siblings of children with autism. Many children in whom autism was established later, however, had no diagnosis yet at 18 or 24 months. An early assessment is therefore usually reliable, but an inconspicuous finding at this age does not rule out autism. If worries persist, repeating it makes sense.

What “stability” means

In research, “stable” means that an early diagnosis is confirmed at a later examination. This matters because in very young children development changes quickly and features can change. Stability says nothing about how a child develops further, which support they need or how pronounced the features are later.

When the diagnosis is made early

Ozonoff and colleagues evaluated examinations of 418 younger siblings of children with autism from seven centres. The children were examined at 18, 24 and 36 months, each with a clinical judgement of “autism” or “not autism”. For children who received the diagnosis at 18 months, it was confirmed in 93 % of cases, at 24 months in 82 %. Only a few children with a diagnosis at this age did not have it confirmed at 36 months. [3]

Guthrie and colleagues examined 82 children found through an early detection programme (FIRST WORDS). They were on average 19 and 37 months old. In a comprehensive examination with observation in the clinic and at home, the judgement (“autism” or “not autism”) stayed the same in all cases. In 17 % the decision was initially deferred. The observation procedure ADOS-T for toddlers showed in comparison excellent sensitivity and acceptable specificity. [2]

When the diagnosis is not yet made

The same sibling study also shows the other side. Of the children who had an autism diagnosis at 36 months, 63 % had not yet been judged to be on the autism spectrum at 18 months and 41 % at 24 months. Almost half were therefore not yet recognised at 24 months. The authors conclude that children with early indications of difficulties in social communication should continue to be observed even if they do not at first meet the criteria. Screening should be repeated several times in the first years. [3] In Guthrie’s study too, the decision was initially deferred for 17 % of children. [2]

How features change over time

A meta-analysis of 40 studies with 5,771 people aged 7 months to 16.5 years examined how severity on the observation procedure ADOS changes over at least twelve months. At group level, severity stayed remarkably stable across childhood. Calibrated severity did not change; in the area “social interaction” there was a small improvement and in repetitive, restricted behaviours none. Whether the criteria for autism remained met did not change overall. In 18 %, the classification shifted from “autism” to “autism spectrum”. The authors stress that individual courses can change even if the group seems stable. [1]

In Guthrie’s study, social interaction scores improved in children with and without autism. In children with autism, repetitive behaviours increased; this was explained by non-verbal developmental level. [2]

What this means for families

According to these studies an early diagnosis is usually reliable. If professionals first wait and see or say “not yet clear”, it can make sense to arrange a follow-up appointment rather than use it only when there are serious problems. This is an inference in the spirit of the studies cited and not an instruction.

How the route works in Germany is described in the articles Autism assessment in children: who, where, how? and First signs in infants and toddlers. For support before and alongside the diagnosis the article Early intervention in autism helps.

What we know and what is open

What we know. A diagnosis made in the second year of life is mostly confirmed in the groups studied. [2] [3] At group level, severity stays largely stable across childhood. [1]

Open.

  • The figures come from research projects, some from families with increased risk (sibling study). They do not necessarily apply to all children. [3]
  • The samples are partly small; in Guthrie’s study it is 82 children. [2]
  • The meta-analysis sees the reporting quality of the studies as limited. Drop-outs at follow-up examinations can distort the picture. [1]
  • For individual children nothing can be predicted with certainty from group figures. [1]

You might also be interested in

Sources and literature

  1. Bieleninik Ł, Posserud MB, Geretsegger M, Thompson G, Elefant C, Gold C: Tracing the temporal stability of autism spectrum diagnosis and severity as measured by the Autism Diagnostic Observation Schedule: A systematic review and meta-analysis. PLOS ONE 2017;12(9):e0183160. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0183160 (frei lesbar, CC BY) – Systematic review with meta-analysis (40 studies, 5,771 people)
  2. Guthrie W, Swineford LB, Nottke C, Wetherby AM: Early diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder: stability and change in clinical diagnosis and symptom presentation. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry 2013;54(5):582-590. https://doi.org/10.1111/jcpp.12008 – Cohort study (82 children)
  3. Ozonoff S, Young GS, Landa RJ, Brian J, Bryson S, Charman T, Chawarska K, Macari SL, Messinger D, Stone WL, Zwaigenbaum L, Iosif A: Diagnostic stability in young children at risk for autism spectrum disorder: a baby siblings research consortium study. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry 2015;56(9):988-998. https://doi.org/10.1111/jcpp.12421 (Baby Siblings Research Consortium) – Cohort study (418 siblings)

You might also be interested in

Found a mistake?

If something is factually wrong, out of date or unclear, let us know. You do not have to give any personal details.

Write a noteClose note

What is wrong? A source helps us check it. At least 10 characters.

Only for follow-up questions about this note. Deleted as soon as it has been dealt with. More in the privacy policy.

Support Autismus WissenBooks & further reading