In brief
A 2022 Cochrane review found that music therapy in autism probably increases the chance of general improvement, lowers the overall severity of features and slightly improves quality of life; the certainty of the evidence was rated as moderate. For social interaction and communication it found no clear difference. Other reviews report larger effects but in very inconsistent studies. Music therapy does not replace assessment or overall planning of support.
What music therapy is
Music therapy uses musical experiences and the relationship that arises in them to make communication and expression possible. It has been used in autism since the 1950s. Its availability differs by country and facility. It requires special academic and clinical training so that therapists can tailor it to the person. [1] Two main forms occur, namely education-oriented music therapy and improvisational music therapy. [2]
The 2022 Cochrane review
Geretsegger and colleagues evaluated 26 studies with 1,165 participants. Duration ranged from three days to eight months, there were individual and group settings, and 21 studies concerned children aged 2 to 12. Half of the studies came from North America or Asia.
Immediately after treatment, compared with sham treatment or usual care, general improvement was seen more often (risk ratio 1.22, 8 studies with 583 participants, moderate certainty of evidence). Arithmetically, about 11 people must be treated for one additional person to benefit, in a group with higher baseline risk about 6. Quality of life was slightly better (SMD 0.28, 3 studies with 340 participants). There was also a probably large reduction in the overall severity of the features of autism (SMD −0.83, 9 studies with 575 participants).
For social interaction and non-verbal and verbal communication the review found no clear difference. There the certainty of the evidence is low or very low, and the true effects can turn out clearly different. On undesired effects there were two studies without notable differences. [1]
The authors conclude that music therapy probably increases the chance of overall improvement and probably improves overall severity and quality of life. It probably does not increase undesired effects immediately after treatment. The results apply to the age groups studied; no direct conclusions can be drawn on adults. [1]
Other reviews
A meta-analysis of 18 studies and 1,457 children (Shi and colleagues, 2024) found clearly better scores for language and communication (SMD −1.20) and social skills (SMD −1.13) as well as for behaviour, sensory perception and self-care. The differences between studies are very large (heterogeneity 80 to 97 %). The studies differ in choice of music, duration and criteria for the therapists. The authors call for more careful studies. [3]
Mayer-Benarous and colleagues (2021) reviewed 39 studies in children with developmental disorders. Education-oriented music therapy had a positive effect in most controlled studies (6 of 7), above all on spoken language. Improvisational music therapy had a positive effect in most (6 of 8), above all on social functioning. Children with autism and intellectual disability responded better. Most studies were small and often without random allocation. [2]
Why the results diverge
The evaluations reach different results. The Cochrane review finds no clear effect for social interaction and communication, the 2024 meta-analysis finds large effects. [1] [3] Possible reasons are the choice of studies, the outcome measures and the rating of the certainty of evidence. This is an assessment by the editorial team, because the summaries we read do not explain the difference. For families this means being cautious about promises that music therapy “improves language or social behaviour”.
What you can take from this
Music therapy can be a supplementary service, especially if a child likes music and makes contact more easily through music. It does not, however, replace assessment or overall planning. Important are qualified training of the therapists and clear goals by which the benefit can be measured. To put services into context, the articles Which support helps? Overview and classification and Evidence on therapies at a glance help.
What we know and what is open
What we know. For children aged 2 to 12 there are moderately certain indications of general improvement, lower severity and slightly better quality of life. Undesired effects were hardly observed. [1]
Open.
- For social interaction and communication the evidence is uncertain and contradictory. [1] [3]
- Long-term effect and adults have hardly been studied. [1]
- Which form, education-oriented or improvisational, suits whom is open. The studies are inconsistent. [2] [3]
- Undesired effects were recorded in only two studies. [1]
You might also be interested in
- Autism-specific therapy and support
- What support helps? Overview and context
- Evidence on therapies at a glance
- Financing autism therapy: who pays, who is responsible?
Sources and literature
- Geretsegger M, Fusar-Poli L, Elefant C, Mössler KA, Vitale G, Gold C: Music therapy for autistic people. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2022;(5):CD004381. https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD004381.pub4 (online 09.05.2022) – Cochrane review (26 studies, 1,165 people)
- Mayer-Benarous H, Benarous X, Vonthron F, Cohen D: Music Therapy for Children With Autistic Spectrum Disorder and/or Other Neurodevelopmental Disorders: A Systematic Review. Frontiers in Psychiatry 2021;12:643234. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyt.2021.643234 (frei lesbar, CC BY; online 09.04.2021) – Systematic review (39 studies)
- Shi Z, Wang S, Chen M, Hu A, Long Q, Lee Y: The effect of music therapy on language communication and social skills in children with autism spectrum disorder: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Frontiers in Psychology 2024;15:1336421. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2024.1336421 (frei lesbar, CC BY; online 07.05.2024) – Systematic review with meta-analysis (18 studies, 1,457 children)
You might also be interested in
Knowledge articleTherapies & support
TEACCH and structured support
Knowledge articleTherapies & support
Autism-specific therapy and support
Knowledge articleTherapies & support
Behavioural early interventions (ABA, ESDM): evidence and criticism
Knowledge articleTherapies & support
Social skills training for adolescents and adults
Found a mistake?
If something is factually wrong, out of date or unclear, let us know. You do not have to give any personal details.
