In brief
Whether support works depends on what is measured. An overview of 64 studies found many different behavioural measures and observation systems, which makes comparison harder. Quality of life, which adults on the autism spectrum name as the most important outcome, was recorded in only about one in four studies on mental health. When reading studies it is worth asking whether what was measured means something to those affected.
Many measures, little comparability
Godoy and colleagues screened 64 studies on non-drug services that used observational, everyday or neurophysiological measures. They found 14 different measures, most often the observation procedure ADOS. For everyday observations there were 37 coding systems in 51 studies, mostly with different protocols, and for brain measurements 24 measures in 16 studies. The authors warn that this variety makes comparisons and conclusions harder. [2] Measuring severity is also inconsistent. In treatment studies with children there were big differences in recording communication, thinking and everyday functioning. [5]
An example: the clinical global impression (CGI)
The “Clinical Global Impressions” scale is an overall judgement by the professional on severity and improvement and is recommended for drug studies. Glod and colleagues found 22 studies that used it for psychosocial services, but with very different meanings, application and evaluation. This limits reliability and informative value. The authors call for standardisation, trained use and additional tested procedures that capture “meaningful, person-centred change”. [1]
What counts for those affected?
Timmerman and colleagues examined randomised studies on mental health in adults on the autism spectrum. Of 19 studies, only five recorded quality of life, an outcome that those affected describe as particularly important. Three of these had community involvement. They call for using tested quality-of-life measures for people on the autism spectrum and involving those affected more. [6]
A short overview by Liñares-de-Marcos and colleagues brings together neurodiversity-oriented views and quality-of-life models and derives six principles. These include that well-being depends on self-acceptance and on the quality of support and that support is a means to participation and not a threat to identity. Support should promote self-determination, belonging and development without forcing adaptation to a norm. This is a concept article and not a study. [3]
Example from a recent study
In an evaluation of data on 582 children from eleven datasets, developmental level, everyday skills and ADOS severity were measured. The ADOS score fell over time with a support programme (ESDM). Whether this is the same as everyday progress is a question in itself. [4] This shows that a number does not necessarily improve where it counts in everyday life.
How you can put study results into context
As suggestions from the editorial team without a study finding, you can ask the following questions. Which measure was used, and who filled it in: a professional, the parents or those affected themselves? Was only one feature of autism measured or also well-being and participation? Is there a follow-up? Does the measure fit what is important for you or your child? Further guidance is offered by the articles How good is a study? Evidence explained, Evidence on therapies at a glance and Which support helps? Overview and classification.
What we know and what is open
What we know. For studies on support in autism, uniform measures are lacking. Frequently used procedures are applied inconsistently, and quality of life is rarely measured. [2] [1] [6]
Open.
- Which measures those affected consider most important and how they can be recorded reliably. [6]
- Whether a set of minimum measures will become established. So far it is only a demand by the authors. [5] [1]
- How suitable measures are for people with high support needs. This has hardly been studied. [3]
- The reviews look at different sub-areas, and there is no overall picture.
You might also be interested in
- How good is a study? Evidence and recommendations explained
- Evidence on therapies at a glance
- What support helps? Overview and context
- Who is missing in autism research?
Sources and literature
- Glod M, Grahame V, Rodgers J: The Use of the Clinical Global Impressions Scale in Psychosocial Interventions for Autism Characteristics: A Systematic Review. Autism 2026;30(10):2481-2494. https://doi.org/10.1177/13623613261472939 (frei lesbar, CC BY; online 09.08.2026) – Systematic review (22 studies)
- Godoy PBG, Sumiya FM, Seda L, Shephard E: A systematic review of observational, naturalistic, and neurophysiological outcome measures of nonpharmacological interventions for autism. Brazilian Journal of Psychiatry 2022;44(5):532-547. https://doi.org/10.47626/1516-4446-2021-2222 (frei lesbar, CC BY-NC) – Systematic review (64 studies)
- Liñares-de-Marcos J, Palomero-Sierra B, Sánchez-Gómez V, Fernández-Álvarez CJ, Canal-Bedia R: An integrative approach between neurodiversity perspectives and quality of life models for autistic people across the spectrum of support needs. Frontiers in Psychiatry 2025;16:1756323. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyt.2025.1756323 (frei lesbar, CC BY; online 05.01.2026) – Short overview (mini review)
- Mandelli V, Busuoli EM, Godel M, Kojovic N, Sinai-Gavrilov Y, Gev T, et al.: Predicting early intervention outcomes in autism via individual participant data mega-analysis. Molecular Autism 2026;17(1):33. https://doi.org/10.1186/s13229-026-00736-x (frei lesbar, CC BY-NC-ND; online 04.08.2026) – Mega-analysis of individual participant data (582 children)
- Stedman A, Taylor B, Erard M, Peura C, Siegel M: Are Children Severely Affected by Autism Spectrum Disorder Underrepresented in Treatment Studies? An Analysis of the Literature. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders 2019;49(4):1378-1390. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10803-018-3844-y (frei lesbar, CC BY) – Literature analysis (367 treatment studies)
- Timmerman A, Totsika V, Lye V, Crane L, Linden A, Pellicano E: Quality-of-life measurement in randomised controlled trials of mental health interventions for autistic adults: A systematic review. Autism 2025;29(3):579-595. https://doi.org/10.1177/13623613241287586 (frei lesbar, CC BY) – Systematic review (19 studies)
You might also be interested in
Knowledge articleScience & research
Who is missing in autism research?
Knowledge articleScience & research
AI and biomarkers in diagnosis: state of research
Knowledge articleScience & research
Is autism hereditary? Genes, family and risk
Knowledge articleScience & research
Autism and parenting: why parenting mistakes are not a cause
Found a mistake?
If something is factually wrong, out of date or unclear, let us know. You do not have to give any personal details.
